Quick answer: Order your usual U.S. shoe size. A cowboy boot should feel snug across the instep, give your toes room to wiggle, and slip about 1/4 inch at the heel until the sole breaks in.
The instep is the key
Boots have no laces, so the instep holds your foot in place. It should feel like a firm handshake — snug, not painful. Classic styles like our square toe boots fit this way.
A little heel slip is normal
New leather soles are stiff, so your heel lifts a little when you walk. It settles as the sole flexes. Too much slip means the boot is too big.
Toe shape changes the feel
A square toe gives more room; a pointed toe like our pointed toe boots is narrower at the tip but the size stays the same.
Women's sizes
Women's boots such as our knee-high cowgirl boots use U.S. women's sizes, about 1.5 sizes larger than men's for the same foot.
Frequently asked questions
Should I size down in cowboy boots?
Usually no. Start with your normal U.S. size.
How long do boots take to break in?
A few weeks of regular wear for most leather boots.
Shop the store: cowboy boots · cowboy hats · western belts. Free U.S. shipping on orders $75+, 30-day returns on unworn items.